Claim Contacts We are available to report your claims for you but If you would like to do it yourself the numbers are provided below. Insurance Contact Numbers: Foremost - 1 (800) 527-3907 National General Ins. - 1 (800) 468-3466 Nationwide - 1 (800) 421-3535 Progressive - 1 (800) 776-4737 Safeco - 1 (800) 332-3226 Travelers - 1 (800) 252-4633